“Our ROAS is 6x, but somehow there’s no money in the bank.”
I hear some version of this every month. The founder is not wrong about the ROAS. Ads Manager is not lying either. The problem is that ROAS measures revenue, and businesses survive on profit.
This article explains the gap between the two and gives you a simple framework to make advertising decisions on profit.
What ROAS does and doesn’t tell you
ROAS (return on ad spend) = revenue attributed to ads ÷ ad spend.
It is a useful efficiency metric, but it ignores almost everything that decides whether you make money:
| ROAS includes | ROAS ignores |
|---|---|
| Attributed revenue | Product cost (COGS) |
| Ad spend | Courier and packaging, often in both directions |
| Returns, refusals and cancellations | |
| Payment and platform fees | |
| Discounts | |
| Whether the customer ever buys again |
In a cash-on-delivery market like Pakistan, the gap is even larger, because Ads Manager counts orders placed, not orders delivered and paid.
Step 1: Calculate your contribution margin per order
Contribution margin is what is left from an order after the costs that come with that order.
Contribution margin = Selling price − Product cost − Delivery and packaging − Payment fees − Expected cost of returns
Example (illustrative numbers):
| Item | Rs |
|---|---|
| Selling price | 4,000 |
| Product cost | 1,600 |
| Delivery and packaging | 300 |
| Payment and platform fees | 100 |
| Expected cost of returns | 300 |
| Contribution margin before ads | 1,700 |
Step 2: Find your break-even ROAS
Break-even ROAS = Selling price ÷ Contribution margin before ads
In the example above: 4,000 ÷ 1,700 ≈ 2.35x.
Any campaign below 2.35x loses money on the first order. A campaign at 3x makes a profit. A campaign at 6x is excellent, if the assumptions about returns hold.
This one number changes how a team reads Ads Manager. “ROAS 2x” stops sounding fine when everyone knows break-even is 2.35x.
Step 3: Adjust for delivery rate
If you sell on COD, adjust reported ROAS by your delivery rate:
Delivered ROAS = Reported ROAS × Delivery rate
A campaign reporting 4x with an 80% delivery rate is really delivering about 3.2x. If break-even is 2.35x, it is still profitable. With a 60% delivery rate, it drops to 2.4x, barely break-even.
Step 4: Add the second order
ROAS only sees the first purchase. Research by Frederick Reichheld of Bain & Company, published in Harvard Business Review, found that increasing customer retention by 5% can increase profits by 25% to 95%. Customers you keep are far cheaper to sell to again than new ones.
For performance marketing, this means a campaign that is only break-even on the first order can be very profitable over 6–12 months if the customers it brings come back.
The profit-first dashboard
Replace “ROAS” as your headline metric with a short dashboard:
| Metric | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Break-even ROAS | The line every campaign must clear |
| Delivered ROAS | Real revenue after COD refusals |
| Cost per delivered order | What a real customer costs you |
| Contribution margin after ads | Actual profit per order |
| Repeat purchase rate (60–90 days) | Long-term value of the customers ads bring |
Common mistakes I see
- Scaling on ROAS alone. Doubling the budget on a campaign that is below break-even doubles the losses.
- Ignoring returns. High-return products can make a great-looking ROAS unprofitable.
- Cutting campaigns that bring repeat buyers. Some campaigns look average on first-order ROAS but bring the best long-term customers.
- Discounting to boost ROAS. Discounts raise volume but lower contribution margin, so break-even ROAS rises.
Key takeaways
- ROAS measures revenue efficiency, not profit.
- Calculate contribution margin and break-even ROAS for each product.
- In COD markets, adjust reported ROAS by delivery rate.
- Include repeat purchases when judging the value of a campaign.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good ROAS?
A good ROAS is one above your break-even ROAS. It depends entirely on your margins, delivery costs and return rates.
How do I calculate break-even ROAS?
Divide your selling price by your contribution margin before ads. For example, Rs 4,000 ÷ Rs 1,700 ≈ 2.35x.
Why is my ROAS high but my profit low?
Usually because of product costs, delivery costs, returns and discounts that ROAS does not include, or because reported orders are not all delivered.
Hasan Farid Joyia is the Founder & CEO of Marksol and helps brands build profitable performance marketing, e-commerce growth and go-to-market strategies.
Sources
- Frederick F. Reichheld and W. Earl Sasser Jr., “Zero Defections: Quality Comes to Services”, Harvard Business Review, 1990, and Bain & Company research on loyalty economics