If you sell online in Pakistan, cash on delivery (COD) is both your best friend and your biggest silent cost.

It is your friend because it removes the main fear shoppers have: “What if I pay and nothing arrives?” A nationally representative Gallup & Gilani Pakistan survey found that about six in ten online shoppers pay by cash on delivery, and other surveys put the share of shoppers who prefer COD at close to 70%.

It is your silent cost because every parcel that comes back, refused at the door or undeliverable, is money already spent and never recovered.

There is no official “national RTO rate”, and that matters

You will see many numbers online for Pakistan’s return-to-origin (RTO) rate. Some guides quote 18–20%. Others say higher. The honest answer is that there is no audited national figure. Return rates vary hugely by category, price point, city, courier and, most of all, by how a brand runs its COD process.

That is actually good news. It means your RTO rate is largely within your control.

What a returned parcel really costs

Most founders underestimate the cost of a return because they only count the courier fee. Here is a fuller picture for a single failed COD order:

Cost itemPaid even if the parcel comes back?
Ad cost to get the orderYes
PackagingYes
Forward courier chargeYes
Return courier charge (depending on contract)Often yes
Staff time for confirmation, packing and follow-upYes
Product damage or ageing in transitSometimes
Cash flow locked while the parcel travelsYes

A simple way to see the impact: if one in four COD parcels fails, and each failure wipes out the margin of the deliveries around it, a batch of four orders can end up earning close to nothing. At one in ten, the same business can be healthy. Your RTO rate can decide whether ads are profitable at all.

Why COD orders fail

From the hundreds of stores and campaigns I have reviewed, failed COD orders usually come from six causes:

  1. The order was never genuine: wrong numbers, duplicates, prank orders.
  2. Impulse faded: the gap between ordering and delivery gives the buyer time to change their mind.
  3. Expectation mismatch: the product looked different, or size, colour or material did not match.
  4. Surprise at the door: delivery charges or the total were not clear before dispatch.
  5. The buyer could not be reached: incomplete address, phone off, nobody home.
  6. Slow delivery: the buyer bought the item elsewhere while waiting.

Every one of these can be reduced with process, not just with a better courier.

The 7-step system to reduce COD returns

1. Confirm every order before dispatch

Send a WhatsApp message within minutes of the order with the product, total amount and expected delivery date, and ask the buyer to reply to confirm. Unconfirmed orders get a call. Orders with no response are not shipped.

2. Show the full price before checkout

Put the total, including delivery, next to the Add to Cart button. Global checkout research by the Baymard Institute shows that 40% of abandonment is caused by unexpected extra costs. At the door, a surprise total is even more likely to become a refusal.

3. Make the product page honest and specific

Use real photos, size charts, material details and a short video if possible. The closer the product is to what the buyer imagined, the fewer refusals.

4. Flag high-risk orders

Hold for extra confirmation: very large first-time orders, incomplete addresses, numbers that never answer, and customers with a history of refusals.

5. Reward prepaid orders

Offer a small discount, free delivery or faster dispatch for paying online through JazzCash, Easypaisa or cards. State Bank data shows e-wallets already account for the vast majority of digital e-commerce transactions in Pakistan, so the habit is growing.

6. Ask for a small advance on high-value items

For products above a set price, ask for a delivery fee or a small token amount upfront. Serious buyers usually agree.

7. Track RTO by city, product and campaign

Do not look at one overall return rate. Break it down. You will often find that one product, one city or one ad audience causes a large share of failures. Fix or pause that, and the overall rate drops.

Measure delivered revenue, not orders placed

This is the single most important mindset shift. Meta Ads Manager and Shopify both count orders placed. Your bank account counts orders delivered and paid. Judge every campaign on delivered revenue and margin after returns.

Key takeaways

Frequently asked questions

What is a good COD return rate in Pakistan?
There is no audited benchmark. Many sellers aim to keep returns well below 20%, and well-run brands with order confirmation often do much better. Track your own rate by product and city.

Does WhatsApp order confirmation really reduce returns?
Yes. It removes fake and impulse orders before they cost you courier fees, and it gives genuine buyers a clear expectation of price and delivery time.

Should I stop offering COD?
For most Pakistani brands, no. Keep COD, but confirm orders and make prepaid payment more attractive.


Hasan Farid Joyia is the Founder & CEO of Marksol, an e-commerce growth agency in Lahore, and Head of Marketing at Pakistan Tech Alliance.

Sources

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *